Get a 'Clue'
Literally. Any Bal’more folk own the game Clue and want to teach me how to play? I need to code up a game based on Clue, and I’ve never even played the original! (This is b/c it required writing, so we couldn’t play on Shabbos, hence we never played…) Anyway, one of my classmates was trying to explain the logic to me.
She said, “All the information available to the players is false; all the information that is hidden is true.”
“Hmm, sounds like an aphorism about life,” I responded.
She laughed, but it got me thinking. Perhaps my off-the-cuff remarks weren’t utterly specious. The idea lingered in the back my mind and crept into the forefront while reading the following on another blog:
In his sefer Sha’arei Orah, R’ Avigdor Miller suggests that one of the reasons we are lazy in our efforts to come to a more profound understanding of Hashem’s exaltedness is because we erroneously think that since the aspects of Hashem that are hidden from us are infinite, it is impossible for us to truly fathom his greatness His greatness. Furthermore, we defend our behavior with the argument that we shouldn’t be attempting the impossible, especially if He hid Himself! Rationalize it as we might, we cannot deny the fact that we have a tremendous obligation to contemplate, to reflect, in order to continuously increase out recognition of Hashem bit by bit. Granted, this obligation knows no bounds, but we must do everything we can. We should follow the example of Dovid HaMelech. Though he declared "ולגדולתו, אין חקר" (Psalms 145:3) he nonetheless said " וגדולתך אספרנה"(Psalms 145:6).
She said, “All the information available to the players is false; all the information that is hidden is true.”
“Hmm, sounds like an aphorism about life,” I responded.
She laughed, but it got me thinking. Perhaps my off-the-cuff remarks weren’t utterly specious. The idea lingered in the back my mind and crept into the forefront while reading the following on another blog:
Bertrand Russell (a British philosopher and mathematician who was a foremost proponent of atheism in the early twentieth century) once was asked what he will respond if after he dies he meets God and He will judge him for his lack of belief. Russell responded that he would ask God, why did You not provide sufficient evidence of Your existence. Hashem might respond, why didn’t you exercise your common sense and look beyond the secular surface of the world, and see the overwhelming evidence of My existence and of My Holy Torah.And even many of us refuse to look beyond the surface as well. But why?
In his sefer Sha’arei Orah, R’ Avigdor Miller suggests that one of the reasons we are lazy in our efforts to come to a more profound understanding of Hashem’s exaltedness is because we erroneously think that since the aspects of Hashem that are hidden from us are infinite, it is impossible for us to truly fathom his greatness His greatness. Furthermore, we defend our behavior with the argument that we shouldn’t be attempting the impossible, especially if He hid Himself! Rationalize it as we might, we cannot deny the fact that we have a tremendous obligation to contemplate, to reflect, in order to continuously increase out recognition of Hashem bit by bit. Granted, this obligation knows no bounds, but we must do everything we can. We should follow the example of Dovid HaMelech. Though he declared "ולגדולתו, אין חקר" (Psalms 145:3) he nonetheless said " וגדולתך אספרנה"(Psalms 145:6).
6 Comments:
At 10:06 PM, MYG said…
Sounds like, "Oilam hafuch ra'isi."
Moshe
At 10:30 PM, Eli7 said…
While i certainly don't argue with your premise, that doesn't change the fact that accepting that no matter how much we explore, we won't actually come out with the whole answer is one of the hardest things a human could do. People do not like accepting that our wisdom is finite and there is an infinte being we will never fully comprehend. it's much easier to say that if we can't understand it, it can't possibly exist. Introspection and contemplation are hard. (And so, all you "hard science" majors, philosophy ain't so easy either - cuz thinking IS hard! Power to liberal arts majors!) ;) And btw, Devorah, you should go out and buy Clue - it's a good game.
At 11:02 PM, Eli7 said…
And in case anyone was wondering, Confucious agrees, As i was doing my reading for East Asian Civ (it's required - i did not choose it), i came across this: "he recognizes that it will not always be given to human beings to understand Heaven's functioning, an insight that shows up in his conversations and observations in a distinctive and often poignant interplay of confidence and resignation... There is something remarkably subtle about this view and something immensely powerful as well." So, while it's not soemthing easy to accept, the fact that you can accept it only makes it greater. (coincidence that i found this at the same time that i read this post? i think not. see? we can see hashgacha in everyday life - Hashem isn't so hidden if we're looking ;)
At 11:03 PM, TRW said…
See? Everything's an analogy for life..
Good point, tho.
Eli7, AMEN to the cheers for the liberal arts majors ;)
Devorah, if you need the game, I have it..come over and play sometime! (Or would that be dangerous..hmmm..)
At 8:31 PM, Keren Perles said…
Amen V'Amen!
And Vora, I love the way you like to take day-to-day stuff as metaphors for something much deeper--Yosher Kochaich!
At 1:17 PM, David Wachtendonk said…
Hi,
I am acutally am a murder mystery (clue) writer. If you want an insight to the logic of creating a game let me know.
Dave
www.host-a-murder.com
dave@host-a-murder.com
Post a Comment
<< Home